|
Post by elliotsluv on Sept 26, 2007 13:01:57 GMT -5
Wow... I think they call that marriage. *giggle* men & women do it all the time... get married, have children, enjoy a family... Look, I like the fantacy of Liv & El, but in reality, I think it would bust the show... El & Liv are great as they are, very close, partners & a bit of sexual tention there... I think Elliot is home where he belongs with Kathy & the kids... in a world full of divorce, it's nice to see a couple work it out. That's just my opinion.
|
|
|
Post by Sexystablersgal on Sept 26, 2007 13:56:12 GMT -5
I hate the idea of Elliot being married, but I think, IMHO, that him and Kathy are suited. ALthought, what the hell is up with Wolf, getting them divorced, then have them being each others booty calls? That didn't seem massivly realistic, IMO, as Elliot is Catholic (not sure about Kathy) so wouldn't that clash with what he belives in???
|
|
|
Post by oowsvu on Sept 26, 2007 14:40:01 GMT -5
he stated before to i think it was Becca that yes divorce is a sin! so is sex without being married! hmmmmmmm! dunno!
also i am not talking about EO! like i just stated booty call is a SIN! if they are Catholic then wtf!
|
|
|
Post by Finaddict on Sept 26, 2007 15:46:25 GMT -5
I think Kathy is also Catholic, to answer that question. I think Kathy has issues she needs to deal with also. Accepting her husband's occupation and not walking out on him are 2 of them. Catholics teach that sex out side of marriage is a sin, BUT El and Kathy were never divorced in the first place. There was no court date that I know of in the show or mentioned on the show. Elliot could sign all the papers he wanted or didn't want to and so could Kathy but if neither goes to Court ain't divorced ;D I myself like the E/O partnership and I like the E/K marriage. Elliot needs both those women in his life.
|
|
|
Post by oowsvu on Sept 27, 2007 8:11:21 GMT -5
i am not even going to comment on EO because this is a STABLER FAMILY THREAD! first off i didnt realize that the courtdate hadnt been set! i know that the papers mean nothing until the judges sees and signs them too! BUT i just think that he is not necessarily in love with her and she is NOT, as she stated, in love with him! all she said was that she cared what happened to him because they had 4 kids and were together all of their adult lives! ALSO bed buddies doesnt imply love either! LIV/BRI for example! she just was in it for the LOVIN and NOT the LOVE! he may have been in it for more but we will never know! LOL!
|
|
|
Post by Sexystablersgal on Sept 27, 2007 14:46:22 GMT -5
Oh, I totally didn't realise that Kathy and El were technically divorced! *doi* Also i agree with ya there Finaddict, he does need both women in his life, the whole disaster with Lv in comp. crimes then him with the she devil proves that! lol. But, and I know, another question, I'm so very irratating, but wouldn't it then mean that El was being almost unfaithful to Kathy when he snogged the face *shudder* off the she devil?? *confused* Also, I'm not sure about the whole 'Kathy/El love' thing, because I think they care deeply about each other, but I'm not sure if it's still love, not like what they used to have. I think once the baby comes-if the baby comes-and if they decide to give it another go (in which case, Kathy needs to sort out her issues, because El is always gonna be a cop, even if it ain't in sex crimes) then yeah, maybe the deep love will come, but in love competly? At this stage, no, I don't think they are. I mean, it's been what, a year or more since they were together-together? (Oh, *duh*, doesn't taht also mean they can't be divorced legally yet, since don't they need to be separated for something like a year if they wnat to get divorced? I dunno, maybe taht's just English Law (?))
|
|
|
Post by oowsvu on Sept 27, 2007 17:27:03 GMT -5
FINE EVERYONE! YOU JUST WANT TO SHUT ME DOWN I AM OUTTA HERE! NEVER TO RETURN!
|
|
|
Post by Finaddict on Sept 27, 2007 20:29:50 GMT -5
FINE EVERYONE! YOU JUST WANT TO SHUT ME DOWN I AM OUTTA HERE! NEVER TO RETURN! I hope you don't mean that. All ships/relationships are welcome here. It's just debating. No harm was meant.
|
|
|
Post by Sexystablersgal on Sept 28, 2007 1:36:04 GMT -5
oowsvu, no one was trying to shut you down. As Finaddict said, all opinions are welcome here, as are any ships you may have. And, if you read my post, I agreed with you about the El/Kathy thing. It is just debating, and debating means that we need people of two different viewpoints. I hope you stay, as you bring interesting discussion.
|
|
mad4svu
Detective Specialist
Posts: 272
|
Post by mad4svu on Aug 1, 2008 10:22:28 GMT -5
Here's some info about the kids' ages from seasons when it was mentioned. I also included Elliot and Kathy's years of marriage.
Season 1 Elliot & Kathy- Maureen- Kathleen- 12 (Hysteria) Dickie & Elizabeth-
Season 2 Elliot & Kathy- 16 (Asunder) Maureen- 15 (Pixies) and 16 (Pique)* Kathleen- Dickie & Elizabeth- 8 (Count Down)
Season 3 Elliot & Kathy- 17 (Tangled) Maureen- Kathleen- Dickie & Elizabeth- 8 (Competence)
Season 4 Elliot & Kathy- Maureen- Kathleen- Dickie & Elizabeth- 10 (Angels and Appearances)
Season 5 (no mention)
Season 6 Elliot & Kathy- 20 (Contagious; however they were separated) Maureen- Kathleen- 17 (Blood) Dickie & Elizabeth
Season 7 (no mention)
Season 8 Elliot & Kathy- over 20 years (Annihilated) Maureen- Kathleen- 17 (Responsible, Screwed) Dickie & Elizabeth-
Season 9 Maureen- Kathleen- Dickie & Elizabeth-* Eli- born November 17, 2007 (Eli was born the day after of the final DUN DUN which took place November 16)
Season 10 not yet!
Final result now: Elliot and Kathy should be married 24 years Maureen should be 23, almost 24 Kathleen should be 21 Dickie & Elizabeth should be 15 *note: Maureen must have had a birthday between Pixies and Pique **however I should note: in Paternity while giving Tommy Keegan a bath, Kathy said that they last gave their child a bath was 15 years ago however the twins should've been at least 14 years but it does kinda makes sense- Kathy could've been rounding off and their birthday was approaching (February 21 according to Count Down).
Kathleen had been 17 for two years of season 6 and 8 which is beyond ridiculous as SVU had been pretty good of keeping up with their age groups until then. They really messed up her age and I'm hoping in season 10 it would be straighten out. Also, her birthday was kinda shown on her license that Elliot burned up in a restuarant in Responsible- it looked like July to me, can't really make the date, maybe the 11th?
|
|
|
Post by Finaddict on Aug 2, 2008 17:16:36 GMT -5
OMG, I really appreciate the time and attention you have paid to El and Kathy and the kids. I have watched this show since Season 1 and even I was confused. I take it that you like El and Kathy together?
|
|
|
Post by Sexystablersgal on Aug 3, 2008 12:31:33 GMT -5
Wow, thank you for the information! That makes it slightly easier to work things out, thats some hardcore viewing right there! *hugs*
Quick question: Which eppy was it where Dickie and Elizabeth had their Catholic ceromony? How old would they be there? Sorry, completly ignorant about the name of the ceromony, I'm assuming it's sorta the same as at Bar/Bat Mitza? Again, my ignorance is awful!
That's what I got to, although who knows if Dick Wolf managed to hold back the years. But, thats a great way of making money on the side, if he can stop Kathleen at 17 for 2 years! But, being senisble (doesn't happan often people!) it seems kinda stupid that someone hadn't checked that. OK, the show is about the crimes and the unit working them (something Wolf seems to have forgotten recently), but it looks at the detectives lives, so you woulda thought care would be taken with their backstories/kids/partners etc.
|
|
|
Post by Terry on Aug 3, 2008 12:47:46 GMT -5
Quick question: Which eppy was it where Dickie and Elizabeth had their Catholic ceromony? How old would they be there? Sorry, completly ignorant about the name of the ceromony, I'm assuming it's sorta the same as at Bar/Bat Mitza? Again, my ignorance is awful! That was in episode 10 of season 8, "Scheherezade". Catholic confirmations usually happens when a person is between 14-16 years old.
|
|
Dani
Leiutenant
I Can Fly
Posts: 1,513
|
Post by Dani on Aug 3, 2008 13:02:48 GMT -5
Quick question: Which eppy was it where Dickie and Elizabeth had their Catholic ceromony? How old would they be there? Sorry, completly ignorant about the name of the ceromony, I'm assuming it's sorta the same as at Bar/Bat Mitza? Again, my ignorance is awful! That was in episode 10 of season 8, "Scheherezade". Catholic confirmations usually happens when a person is between 14-16 years old. Mine was 16, and they looked to be fourteen when we saw them.
|
|
oliviahouse
Leiutenant
Sarcasm is my Beastie. Muwahaha!
Posts: 1,492
|
Post by oliviahouse on Aug 3, 2008 18:55:17 GMT -5
Hmm, I had my Confirmation this past September. It depends on the different churches, I guess...
|
|